Pros and Cons of Skills-Based Hiring Over Degrees

Nicol Matheson • September 9, 2024

The executive recruitment landscape has seen a notable shift from traditional degree-based hiring to skills-based hiring.

This transition reflects the growing recognition that specific competencies and real-world experience can be more valuable to a company's success than a candidate's formal education.


But what does skills-based hiring over degrees truly entail, and how might it reshape the way we recruit top-level talent?

People in a work setting, sitting on chairs, interacting with each other.

What Does Skills-Based Hiring Over Degrees Mean?


Skills-based hiring refers to evaluating candidates based on their abilities, competencies, and experience rather than focusing solely on their educational qualifications. 


In contrast to the traditional approach, which prioritises degrees and formal credentials, this model emphasises practical skills and knowledge that align directly with job requirements. 


For executive recruitment, this approach means prioritising candidates who demonstrate leadership, problem-solving, and industry-specific skills, regardless of their academic background.


Pros & Cons of Skills-Based Hiring


Pros –


  1. Broader Talent Pool: Skills-based hiring opens up the recruitment process to a larger, more diverse pool of candidates. By not limiting talent searches to degree holders, companies can identify individuals who have developed strong skills through alternative education, on-the-job training, or personal initiative.
  2. Faster Hiring Process: Companies can often identify qualified candidates more quickly by focusing on demonstrated skills rather than screening for specific degrees. This can significantly reduce recruitment time, allowing businesses to fill critical roles faster.
  3. Improved Performance and Retention: Employees hired based on their skills are more likely to excel in their roles. This leads to better job performance and higher employee satisfaction, ultimately improving retention rates.
  4. Cost-Effectiveness: Businesses can reduce the costs associated with lengthy recruitment processes and potentially avoid the higher salary demands often tied to candidates with advanced degrees.


Cons –


  1. Lack of Standardisation: Without degree requirements, it can be more challenging to assess and compare candidates' qualifications on a standardised level.
  2. Overlooking Soft Skills: The focus on technical or job-specific skills may lead to the undervaluing of soft skills like communication, teamwork, and emotional intelligence—critical attributes for executive roles.
  3. Bias Against Traditional Candidates: While skills-based hiring is designed to be inclusive, there's a risk of creating bias against those with traditional qualifications.


Two people shaking hands in a corporate setting.

How to Implement Skills-Based Hiring in Your Executive Recruitment Strategy


With the rise of digital transformation and technological innovation, the demand for adaptable, skilled professionals who can deliver immediate impact has never been higher.

Implementing a skills-based hiring approach requires a fundamental shift in how candidates are assessed. Here are a few steps to consider:


  1. Revise Job Descriptions: Clearly outline the skills, competencies, and experiences necessary for the role. Instead of listing degree requirements, focus on the abilities candidates need to succeed.
  2. Utilise Skill Assessments: Use pre-employment tests or real-world tasks that allow candidates to demonstrate their skills. This can be especially useful for executive roles, where leadership, strategic thinking, and decision-making skills are crucial.
  3. Train Hiring Teams: Ensure your recruitment teams are equipped to evaluate candidates based on their skills. This may involve providing training on how to assess both hard and soft skills effectively.
  4. Promote Internal Mobility: Encourage existing employees to develop new skills and apply for internal positions, creating a culture of continuous learning and growth.


The Future of Executive Recruitment:

A Skills-Based Landscape



As Australia's executive recruitment sector continues to evolve, skills-based hiring is likely to become a dominant strategy. Companies are recognising that while degrees may indicate a level of education, they do not always guarantee the skills needed for leadership success.

In today's fast-paced world, adaptability, problem-solving, and real-world experience are increasingly becoming the currency of talent.


For executive recruitment firms like People Like Us®, staying ahead of this trend means adapting to a new mindset—one where the true value lies not in academic qualifications but in the tangible skills that can drive a company forward.



Contact us for industry-leading insights into hiring the right people.




Contact Us

By Nicol Matheson November 29, 2024
The transition from public practice to commerce is a significant career shift, and one that requires careful planning and insight. Whether you’re looking for a new challenge, greater work-life balance, or the opportunity to be part of a dynamic business environment, 2025 is the perfect time to make the move. But how can you ensure your transition is seamless and successful? Here are some key steps to guide you.
By Nicol Matheson November 18, 2024
As the summer months approach and work slows down, finding yourself "on the bench" can be both a blessing and a challenge. While it may feel unsettling to have idle time, this period offers a unique opportunity to invest in yourself and set the stage for a prosperous 2025. Here are the top five things you should do to make the most of your downtime.
By Nicol Matheson November 7, 2024
As we venture into 2025, Sydney's technology sector is undergoing a remarkable transformation. At People Like Us, we've observed how executive roles are evolving in response to innovation demands and global market dynamics. While artificial intelligence and automation continue to reshape the industry, we believe it's the human element that truly drives success in these pivotal positions.
By Nicol Matheson October 28, 2024
The end of the year often comes with a unique set of recruitment challenges: November and December mark a time of reflection, planning, and often increased demand across many industries. For hiring managers, ensuring that teams are resourced effectively during the festive season is key to hitting the ground running in January. Here are our top five resource planning tips to help you stay one step ahead and meet your recruitment goals.
By Nicol Matheson October 14, 2024
The Australian executive recruitment landscape has undergone a significant transformation over the past five years. As we move beyond the zenith of the pandemic, many professionals are pondering: How has the return to office life unfolded? What strategies are proving effective, and why? In this blog, we delve into the evolution of the workplace in the post-COVID era, examining the nuances of hybrid work models and the delicate equilibrium between home and office life.
By Nicol Matheson October 7, 2024
In today's rapidly evolving business landscape, sustainability has moved from the periphery to the core of corporate strategy.  At People Like Us, we've witnessed firsthand how this shift is reshaping the executive recruitment landscape in Sydney and beyond. Let's delve into the world of sustainability and green jobs, exploring their importance and impact on the hiring market.
By Nicol Matheson September 30, 2024
In today's rapidly evolving business landscape, the ability to adapt and grow is no longer just an asset—it's a necessity. At People Like Us, we've witnessed first-hand how the executive recruitment scene in Australia has transformed. The skills that propelled leaders to the top even a few years ago may not be enough to keep them there today.
By Nicol Matheson September 23, 2024
As we progress through 2024, Australia's economic landscape remains uncertain Rising inflation, high interest rates, and lower-than-expected GDP growth have led to a cautious business environment. For the executive recruitment sector, this has resulted in a slower hiring pace, particularly for senior-level roles.
By Nicol Matheson September 16, 2024
Artificial Intelligence (AI) has been making significant strides across industries, and Australian recruitment is no exception.  While AI is bringing notable improvements to candidate sourcing and screening processes, we at People Like Us believe it's crucial to consider how this technology impacts the candidate experience. After all, recruitment is as much about people as it is about processes.
By Nicol Matheson September 2, 2024
As we progress through 2024, the executive recruitment landscape in Australia continues to evolve. Let's explore the key trends that are influencing high-level hiring and shaping the industry.
More Posts